原曲: Martika - Safe In The Arms Of Love vs 張清芳 - 認真的眼睛
樂意特別號! 感謝Tony的分享同Ogake的info.
Canto-pop favorite: 彭羚 - 三人世界
Album: 彷彿是初戀
彭羚 - 三人世界 (use this if player doesn't show)
Original version: Martika - Safe In The Arms Of Love
Album: Martika's Kitchen
Martika - Safe In The Arms Of Love (use this if player doesn't show)
相似歌:
Canto-pop favorite: 劉美君 - 你的雙眼如深秋
Album: 秋心
劉美君 - 你的雙眼如深秋 (use this if player doesn't show)
Original version: 張清芳 - 認真的眼睛
Album: 認真的眼睛
張清芳 - 認真的眼睛 (use this if player doesn't show)
彭羚: 三人世界 vs 劉美君: 你的雙眼如深秋
.
..
12 comments:
我又有聽彭羚,又有聽Martika, 但一直都沒有把這兩首歌connected到until Tony sent來的email. 而家把它們放在一起聽, 突然對它們的觀感又有所唔同, 尤其是對Martika的原版, 突然又覺得它幾好聽咁, 之前都唔覺有什麼特別的. 有些改編歌就有這樣effect. But definitely not all 改編歌 can do this trick! Some originals are just simply bad material and no plastic surgery can repair!
要再次多謝Tony的慷慨分享. :)
少少題外話: 呢隻歌同劉美君隻"你的雙眼如深秋"副歌好相似,原曲為張清芳《認真的眼睛》
有D咁嘅事...!! :) 等我過一回加埋Prudence隻歌上來驗證下. 不過, 我剛在youtube聽過張清芳《認真的眼睛》, 真的有七成以上似! Ogake, 你真好耳! :)
張清芳 - 認真的眼睛 (MV)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xFUV9aiBJ2I
上載了! 全首歌聽, 我覺得有5成似, 可能Prudence把聲同彭小姐好唔同, 所以沒有張清芳那樣似. 嘩, what a surprise! 你們又覺得有多成似呢?
Guys, 你的雙眼如深秋 is a cover of 認真的眼睛!! I am 100% sure, the melody is the SAME!!
作曲 of 認真的眼睛 is 蔣三省, could someone verify who wrote 你的雙眼如深秋 please?
The reason one might find it hard to identify is because Stella sings it in a higher key as usual.
Didn't know Prudence covered 認真的眼睛!! Very urprised!!!
TONY
我想Prudence是真的covered「認真的眼睛」, but the mystery is why 蔣三省作的這首歌這麼似Martika那隻「Safe In The Arms Of Love」. Could it be a coincidence? :)
Ha ha! I am a shocker!! I missed the whole point of the discussion!!!
It NEVER occurred to me that 認真的眼睛/你的雙眼如深秋 would sounded like Safe in the Arms of Love! But now that you guys mentioned it, I can hear the resemblances. The main difference is Martika's song has a bridge.
VERY interesting...it could be a copy, consider Martika's album came out in 1991, and Stella's came out in 1992.... :-) TONY
Cass的是改編Martika的, 而Prudence那一首, 驟聽好像也是改編自Martika的, 但聽落個melody有少少唔同, 相信同Martika無關.
Cass很適合唱這類歌, 開正佢瓣數!
張學友改編過Martika的I feel the earth move. 你應該已經貼過了?
Martika仲有一首慢版激情歌Toy Soldiers (個人覺得有點似Madonna的Live to Tell), 有沒有人改編過呢?
Toy Soldiers 的 cover 是戴蘊慧的"無家天使"
wow... 戴蘊慧, 我都不知去那裡找了. 不過, thanks m!
Can't believe I have actually found 戴蘊慧的「無家天使」!!! 等我返香港會post上來. Thanks again m... :)
Post a Comment