原曲: Southern All-Stars - いとしのエリー
Canto-pop favorite: 張學友 feat 陳慧嫻 - 給我親愛的
Album: 給我親愛的 Preview
Year: 1989
Canto-pop favorite: 黎明 - Ellie
Album: Leon Now Preview
Year: 1999
Original version: Southern All-Stars - いとしのエリー
Album: 10ナンバーズ・からっ Preview
Year: 1989
張學友 feat 陳慧嫻: 給我親愛的 / 黎明: Ellie
8:00 PM
|
Labels:
[日] Southern All-Stars,
張學友,
陳慧嫻,
黎明
|
This entry was posted on 8:00 PM
and is filed under
[日] Southern All-Stars
,
張學友
,
陳慧嫻
,
黎明
.
You can follow any responses to this entry through
the RSS 2.0 feed.
You can leave a response,
or trackback from your own site.
.
..
5 comments:
Wow, never knew of this collaboration between Jacky & Priscilla!
The first of song Jacky's voice or technique has a strong resemblance of another Mr Cheung (Leslie)!
I have always like SAS & 桑田佳祐-san's music! No exception here! Although I slightly prefer the SAS original (the Jacky back then wasn't "Singing-God" yet)! 桑田佳祐's voice is so nice! Jacky is a good second best here!
當年我非常喜歡這首歌, 覺得學友與慧嫻在歌唱上是完美的一個組合. 雖然今天聽翻才發現原來學友當年的唱腔真的有未完全成熟的階段 (as Griffin suggested). I mean not bad really, just not as perfect as he would be a few years later. :) 桑田佳祐的版又多了一份滄桑味. Like both version.
其實黎明都改過,隻歌叫 Ellie, 收錄於 Leon Now 大碟
我就鍾意學友個版多d啦
加翻黎明的版了... 還是覺得學友好一些!
GC, thanks for sharing! It's a remake 10years after! It's like most remake nowadays: another pointless cover! It adds nothing to it nor make it sounds better/different! I'll stick with my opion: Original is the best then Jacky+Priscilla's! Leon's... mmm... (harsh comments not visible for others)!
Post a Comment